What's The Diff?

I interrupt the Red, White, and Blue series for this installment of What's the Diff?

This is the Field Game Cardigan, originally $118, now $59.95:

This is the Yacht Lace Cardigan, $54.99:

Now I ask you,  unless you have a strong preference for thick or skinny stripes (and white or gold buttons, blah blah), what's the diff?

I suppose if I had to choose, I'd go with the first because I find larger stripes more flattering on me and the sale price is only $5 different from the second.  It also looks a bit longer than the yacht lace cardi.  Thoughts?