These oxfords are from Steven by Steve Madden and are $69.99 ($99 originally):
These oxfords are at Modcloth and are $39.99:
So, the ones from Modcloth are a little...shinier? And aren't real leather? I'm gonna go with WHO CARES on both counts and pick the cheaper ones, since I can't imagine wanting to wear these more than twice before I feel like I've been cast in a musical or, you know, back in the 1950s. As a man.