This is the A Gloss for Words Flat. It's $59.99 at ModCloth.
This is the Restricted Peach Patent Flat. It's $44.95 at DSW.
They are, in fact, the exact same shoe. So what's the diff, you ask? The diff, my dear readers, is that DSW is offering them for $15.04 less than ModCloth, and DSW offers free shipping on orders of $35 or more. My choice is obvious.